Google is answering more of the search itself
For twenty years the deal was simple. Someone searched, Google showed ten links, and some of those people clicked through to your website. That deal is changing fast.
Google now writes an AI answer at the top of many searches, and people read it instead of clicking. The numbers are consistent across every study we trust:
- Pew Research Center tracked the real browsing of 900 US adults. When an AI summary appeared, people clicked a regular result on 8% of visits. Without one, 15%. They clicked a link inside the summary itself on just 1%.
- Seer Interactive found organic click-through on searches with an AI Overview fell 61% between mid-2024 and late 2025.
- Ahrefs looked at 300,000 keywords and found the number one result gets about 58% fewer clicks when an AI Overview sits above it.
One honest caveat: those studies mostly measure "how do I" and "what is" searches. Local searches like "plumber near me" still show the map first, and AI Overviews appear on them less often. But the map is changing too.
In March 2026 Google launched Ask Maps, a Gemini feature in Google Maps that takes questions like "is there a public tennis court with lights I can play at tonight?" and answers from what it knows about more than 300 million places. Google's AI can also call local businesses to check prices and availability for a searcher. And the old Questions and Answers section on business listings has been giving way to AI answers that Google writes for you.
Put simply: more and more people will decide whether to call you without ever opening your website. Whatever Google's AI says about you, it says from the information it has. That's mostly your Google Business Profile, your reviews and your website.
Where the AI gets its answers about you
In September 2026 BrightLocal published the biggest study we've seen on this: around 200,000 local searches run through ChatGPT, Google's AI Mode and AI Overviews, and about 1.9 million citations counted. Three findings matter for an owner.
- Business websites were the most cited source. About 42% of all citations pointed to a business's own site.
- Business Profiles came second, around 28%. Google's own AI leaned on them heavily. ChatGPT barely used them at all.
- Google Maps still named the business most often. A tracked business showed up in 66% of Maps searches, against roughly a third on the AI surfaces.
And people are using these tools. In BrightLocal's 2026 consumer survey, the share of people who use AI tools for local recommendations jumped from 6% to 45% in a year.
So does the website still matter? Yes, more than ever
It's tempting to read the click numbers and decide the website is dead. The data says the opposite. The website isn't always where the customer lands anymore. It's where the AI does its homework.
Whitespark's 2026 Local Search Ranking Factors survey asked 47 local search experts what gets a business named in AI answers. Second on the list: a dedicated page for each service. A Business Profile holds a few hundred words. A website can explain every service, every town you cover, how you price, and what questions customers ask. That's the material an AI needs to recommend you for a specific job.
So the website's job has changed from "brochure people read" to "the full record AI reads." Your profile is the short version. Your site is the long one. When they agree, the AI is confident. When they contradict each other, it hedges or picks someone else. Our guide on getting cited by AI search covers the website side.
Where most profiles stop
Here's the pattern we see with nearly every local business that comes to us. The profile got set up when the business opened. Somebody verified it, added the logo, and started asking happy customers for reviews. Then nothing. The hours are from two winters ago. There's one category. The services list is empty. The last photo is the storefront on opening day.
Reviews matter, and you should keep asking. But reviews are one of more than a dozen things on that profile. Google's own help page says businesses with complete and accurate information are more likely to show up in local results. Now that an AI reads every field to answer questions, a half-empty profile costs you twice: in the map ranking and in what the AI can say about you.
13 steps to take after the reviews
Work through these in order. The first few move rankings the most. The rest make sure the AI has the right answers.
1. Get the primary category exactly right
Whitespark's 2026 survey ranked the primary category as the number one factor for the map results, above proximity. Pick the one category that describes where most of your revenue comes from. Search your main service in Google Maps and note the primary category of the top three businesses. If yours is different, there should be a good reason.
Then add secondary categories sparingly. Google's guidelines say to use as few as possible to describe your core business. Each one should be something you actually do, not a keyword you wish you ranked for.
2. Fill in the services list, one per thing you invoice
Most profiles we audit have an empty or near-empty services section. Open your last twenty invoices, write down every distinct service, and add each one with a short description in plain words. Use the same names your website uses on its service pages, so the profile and the site tell the same story.
3. Write a real business description
You get 750 characters, and only about the first 250 show before "More." Lead with what you do, who you do it for, and where. Skip the slogans. Google's rules say no links, no promotions and no prices here. Google may offer an AI-suggested description in some regions. Treat it as a first draft, not a finished one.
4. Keep hours current, and set special hours before every holiday
"Open at the time of search" made Whitespark's top five map factors. If Google thinks you're closed, you don't show. Set special hours ahead of Thanksgiving, Christmas, the Fourth and the 24th of July. The AI tools answer "are they open right now?" straight from this field, so a wrong answer sends the customer somewhere else.
5. Set service areas properly
If you go to the customer, list the cities or ZIP codes you actually serve. Google allows up to 20, and the whole area shouldn't stretch past about two hours of driving. If customers don't come to you, hide the street address. That's Google's rule for service-area businesses, not just a privacy choice.
6. Check every attribute
Attributes are the checkboxes: wheelchair accessible, women-owned, veteran-owned, online appointments, onsite services, payment types. They're quick to skip and they're exactly what Ask Maps and AI Mode use to answer filtered questions like "who takes cards and can come today?" Go through every one that applies to your category.
7. Add real photos every month
Upload photos of your actual work, your team, your vehicles and your space. Phone photos are fine. Stock photos aren't. A steady trickle beats one big batch, because a profile with recent photos looks like a business that's open and busy, to people and to Google. Video works the same way and few competitors bother.
8. Reply to every review, in your own words
BrightLocal's 2026 survey is clear here. 89% of people expect the owner to reply. 80% are more likely to choose a business that replies to all its reviews. And 50% are put off by replies that read like a template. Name the job, thank them, keep it to two sentences. For bad reviews, stay calm, own what's fair, and take the details offline.
Keep the requests going too. The same survey found 74% of people care about reviews from the last three months, and 31% won't consider a business under 4.5 stars, up from 17% a year earlier. A burst of reviews from 2023 doesn't do much in 2026.
9. Post updates, offers and events
Profile posts haven't been shown to move rankings much on their own, and we won't pretend they do. What they do is keep the profile current and give Google fresh, dated facts: a seasonal special, a new service, an event. That's useful to a customer reading the listing and to an AI looking for what's new. One a week or two is plenty. Reuse what you already post elsewhere.
10. Point your links at the right pages
The website link doesn't have to be your homepage. If most people want to book, link the booking page. Add the appointment or ordering link if your category allows it. If you serve several towns from one profile, the town page may be a better landing spot than the homepage. Wherever it points, make sure that page loads fast on a phone.
11. Move your FAQ to your website
Google has been retiring the old Questions and Answers section and answering questions about businesses with AI instead. You can't write those answers. They're built from your profile, your reviews and your website. So the move is to put a real FAQ on your site: pricing approach, areas served, how booking works, what to expect on the first visit. Answer the questions customers actually ask on the phone.
12. Decide how you want AI to contact you
Two newer settings are worth a look. Google's AI calling feature can phone US businesses to check prices or availability for a searcher, and the profile has a setting to opt out. And Google is testing AI-powered messaging on profiles, where an agent answers routine questions from your profile data and hands off to you. Both work only as well as the hours, services and prices you've entered. If those are wrong, the AI will be confidently wrong on your behalf.
13. Copy it all to Apple Maps and Bing
Google isn't the only map. In BrightLocal's survey, the share of people using Apple Maps to look up businesses rose from 14% to 27% in a year. Claim Apple Business Connect and Bing Places, and copy the same name, address, phone, hours and categories. Matching details everywhere tells every system it's the same business.
Three things not to do
- Don't stuff keywords into the business name. "Smith Plumbing | Best Plumber Salt Lake City" can lift rankings for a while, which is why people do it. It also breaks Google's guidelines, invites competitors to report you, and can get the profile suspended. Use your real name.
- Don't buy, write or filter reviews. The FTC's fake review rule, in force since October 2024, bans fake and paid reviews and carries civil penalties of tens of thousands of dollars per violation. Google can also block new reviews or put a public warning on your profile. Ask everyone, offer nothing in return.
- Don't create a second profile. One business, one profile. Duplicates split your reviews and can get both taken down.
A 20-minute monthly routine
- 5 minutes. Check hours and set special hours for any holiday coming up.
- 5 minutes. Reply to any review you haven't answered.
- 5 minutes. Upload three or four new photos and publish one post.
- 5 minutes. Compare the services list against what you sold this month. Add anything missing, on the profile and the website.
Do the 13 steps once. Then do this every month. That's what separates the profile that was launched from the profile that's working.
Where this comes from: Pew Research Center (July 2025), Seer Interactive (September 2025), Ahrefs (February 2026), Google's Maps blog (March 2026), Whitespark Local Search Ranking Factors 2026 (November 2025), BrightLocal Local Consumer Review Survey 2026 (February 2026), BrightLocal Local AI Visibility Study (September 2026), Google Business Profile help pages and guidelines, and the FTC's fake reviews rule. Read November 16, 2026. The patterns we describe come from profiles we've audited for clients.
Quick answers
Is Google Business Profile more important than a website now?
They do different jobs, and you need both. Google's own AI answers and Google Maps lean heavily on your Business Profile. Other AI tools such as ChatGPT barely use it and read business websites instead. In a 2026 BrightLocal study, business websites were the most cited source in local AI answers and Business Profiles were second.
What is the most important Google Business Profile setting?
The primary category. The experts surveyed for Whitespark's 2026 Local Search Ranking Factors rated it the top factor for the map results. Pick the one category that describes what most of your revenue comes from, and use as few extra categories as possible.
Should I put keywords in my Google Business Profile name?
No. It may help rankings briefly, but Google's guidelines say the name must match your real-world name and that adding unnecessary information is not permitted. Profiles with keyword-stuffed names can be suspended, which costs far more than it gains.
Do I need to reply to every Google review?
Yes, if you can. In BrightLocal's 2026 consumer survey, 89% of people said they expect owners to reply and 80% said they are more likely to use a business that replies to all reviews. Half were put off by replies that read like a template, so write each one yourself and keep it short.
What happened to Questions and Answers on Google Business Profile?
Google has been phasing out the old Q&A section and answering questions about a business with AI instead. Those answers are built from your profile, your reviews and your website, and you cannot write them directly. The way to shape them is to keep the profile complete and put a real FAQ on your website.
How often should I update my Google Business Profile?
Check it once a month, and any time your hours, services or prices change. Reply to reviews within a few days. Add special hours before every holiday. A monthly 20-minute pass covers most businesses.
Want your profile checked?
Send us your business name. We'll go through all 13 steps on your profile and send back what's missing. Free.



